Question bank — photo-expert.moscow

05For a reviewHave the source files been preserved and their provenance described?

06For a reviewIs the conclusion about signs of compositing substantiated in light of compression and processing?

07For a reviewAre observed signs distinguished from assumptions about how the photograph was altered?

08For a reviewDo the conclusions address the questions put to the expert?

09For a reviewAre the source materials and their limitations described adequately?

10For a reviewIs the choice of methods justified for the object of examination?

11For a reviewCan the examination process be verified from the description and appendices?

12For a reviewAre the descriptive section and final conclusions consistent?

13For a reviewAre established facts distinguished from assumptions?

14For a reviewWhich deficiencies may affect the report's validity?

Questions for the expert